Legend:
Especially Interesting General HCI Papers
Papers Having to do with Visualization (of all qualities)
My Comments
These three papers together, from various Xerox research labs, continue the tradition of studying how people read, annotate, and generally consume text. They also make recommendations for the design of online document annotation and present a description of a "active document reader" that does not introduce any novel ideas itself, but puts together a lot of ideas that have been floating around the last few years into one place, using a commercial high-resolution pen-tablet display.
They then present a visualization for showing portions of clan graphs (they don't discuss how this scales to graphs larger than the example which has 29 pages). They started with a standard graph layout and observed the usual problem with spaghetti caused by the in and out links. They then decided not to show the links explicitly, and instead arrange the pages in concentric circles with those pages higher in their respective sites shown closer to the center. User feedback revealed that people didn't like this because they wanted an importance ordering on the documents, so they switched to a concentric semi-circle layout, which I haven't seen before. (However, up to this point this is much like a commercial web analysis tool like InContext WebAnalyzer.) They call this an auditorium view. But instead of showing the links as lines when the document is clicked on, they show the links by greying out those documents NOT linked to by the focus document -- a nice innovation. They also show bitmaps of the pages, which is much better than identical icons, but is slow to generate. They also use color along the rings to show if a page primarily has inlinks or outlinks, but I doubt this is useful.