IS214
Spring 2000
Assignment 1
due Jan 31
Buy and read a daily or weekly
newspaper that has a Web version -- e.g., San Francisco Chronicle or Examiner,
New York Times, or San Jose Mercury News.
First simply read the (paper)
newspaper, as you normally would. In about a page, write a summary
of your experiences, including such factors as:
-
Where did you read it?
(BART, kitchen table, bathroom, cafe...)
-
Did you read it all at once,
or spread out over hours or the day? Pay attention to how
much time you spent reading the paper.
-
What did you look at first?
(Be honest, I won't tell anyone if you only read the horoscope.)
-
What caused you to read the
stories and features that you did? (E.g., location on front page,
habit -- "I always read Jon Carroll", attention-getting headline, a story
you are following...)
-
Did you look for specific things?
(E.g., articles about a particular place, person, or on-going story;
features like columnists and comics; a special section; book reviews).
How easy were they to find?
-
How did the physical affordances
of the paper affect your reading, positively or negatively? (E.g.,
a story was continued from page 1 to a different section of the paper,
which you didn't have; you carried with you only the sections of
the paper you wanted to read; you tore out a story to pass on to
someone else; you read more stories at the bottom of the page because the
paper was lying on the kitchen table while you ate breakfast...)
-
How did the layout and arrangement
of the paper affect your reading? (E.g., the front page guided you
to the most important stories; you knew where to find the columnist you
wanted to read)
-
If you were in a public place
where others were reading the paper during the day -- BART, a cafe -- add
in whatever observations you were able to make of others' behavior that
either reinforced or differed from your experiences.
Now read the next day's issue
online. After you have read it, answer the same questions. In addition,
get the paper version of this issue and compare it to the online version.
(You may be surprised by how it differs, and the stories that get left
out.) Consider:
-
How does the online version
differ from the paper? In layout, tone, style, content...whatever.
-
In particular, is there more
information presented online? Less? Differently laid out?
-
How did your experience differ
between the two versions? Consider not only the physical differences,
and overt differences in your behavior (e.g., reading on BART vs in the
computer lab) but other differences as well -- did you read different articles?
Were there articles that caught your attention in the paper version and
not online, or vice versa? Did you tend to go to different stories,
features, sections? Spend more or less time? Read more or less
thoroughly?
Based you your experiences,
what
recommendations would you make to the designers of the online version?
And what choices would you make yourself between paper and online versions?
Total assignment should be
3-4 pages.