Comparative Analysis - Tracking a conversation on Technorati.com

From Technorati:

Technorati has a search box for entering either a key word or a URL. This allows for finding conversations around a topic, a set of key words, or by location. This location could either be a specific blog post, a specific blog, or a site such as the nytimes.com, which will catch all references to all New York Times articles. However, a specific article can also be searched, so that just that conversation can be tracked.

Technorati also has "Breaking News" which they describe as "Breaking News in the blogosphere, new news items reported in the last 12 hours" and "Current Events" which they describe as "Current Events in the blogosphere, based on new blog entries in the last 3 hours." It is unclear from the results of these two sorts how different they are, other than they are different sorts of conversation. However, other than seeing conversations collected over the last 3 or 12 hours, there is no clear indication as to why "breaking" covers that last 12 hours and "current" covers the last 3 hours. Clicking on the highlighted headline at the top of a conversation will connect to the article from traditional journalism sources, and then the highlighted links below connect to blogs that have discussed this article in the last either 3 or 12 hours.

Other links on the site refer to pages that say "coming soon" such as "newcomers" and "recent blogs". Both links are also confusingly named as they appear to describe the same thing, but since nothing is displayed, I cannot tell what the intension is for the definition of these sorts of data.

Other features include creating a watchlist, viewing the top ranked 100 blogs (ranked because they have the most inbound links) and becoming a member, which for bloggers might make some sense because there are some tracking features and api's that can be obtained with membership. The membership feature is difficult to use, the interaction is not flowing or intuitive, and the resulting instructions in email are difficult understand and see what is necessary in order to complete the blog claiming process.

The "hot products" link is described as "Top products discussed in the last 24 hours". This is a really interesting feature because it appears to link together posts talking about books at Amazon with the cover of the book, organized by the most talked about books first. Visually, it is one of the nicest things about the site because the graphical images of the books is engaging and a nice change from all the text on the site.

Strong points


Weak points