Peer-to-Peer (P2P) Technology: Legal and Policy Challenges
INFOSYS 296A-2 | University of California at Berkeley | SPRING 2005

Professor Pamela Samuelson
E-Mail: pam@sims.berkeley.edu 
Phone: (510) 642-6775
Office Hours:  Tuesdays: 3:15-4:15 (434 North Addition, Boalt Hall);
 Wednesdays: 2:00-3:30 (305B South Hall)
Class Meeting Time: Mondays 4:00-6:00pm, 110 South Hall
URL: http://pam-p2p.notlong.com/
blog: http://groups.sims.berkeley.edu/pam-p2p/

Tutor: Joseph Lorenzo Hall (joehall@pobox.com)
Joe's Office Hours:  Wednesdays 10:00-11:00am (or by appointment);
 at SIMS PhD Offices (on the ground level of South Hall)

The recording industry has initiated many lawsuits against peer to peer file sharing technology developers and individual file sharers. They have also tried to persuade federal prosecutors to bring criminal cases against file sharers and technology developers and sought additional legislation to increase penalties for file sharing and to change dramatically the liability rules for developers of infringement-enabling technologies. For the past twenty years, since the Supreme Court's Sony Betamax decision, technologists have known technologies capable of substantial noninfringing uses could be developed free from copyright owner control, but this may soon change. This seminar will consider a range of policy alternatives available to respond to the challenges P2P technologies and file sharing pose for the entertainment industry and the implications of each alternative.

Students with familiarity with the Internet and its resources or with backgrounds in some of the substantive fields explored in this course are especially welcome, but there are no formal prerequisites. (Some students might appreciate a tutorial on Copyright law.)

REQUIRED READINGS: Students are required to purchase:

COURSE REQUIREMENTS: Students enrolled in this course will be expected to participate in class discussions as well as in the class blog. Each week some students will be asked to do one or more of the recommended readings and be prepared to discuss them in class and/or in the class blog. All students will be expected to write a final paper on his/her policy recommendations about what to do about peer to peer file sharing and file sharing technologies unless the student and instructor have agreed on a paper on another more specific topic.

SYLLABUS: Here is a PDF version of the syllabus as of 26 Jan 2005 which also includes a longer description of the paper requirement: Short Syllabus (PDF).

MAILING LIST: Please sign up for the class mailing list by sending an email to "majordomo@sims.berkeley.edu" with the text "subscribe pam-p2p" in the body of the message. We will use this mailing list for announcements and news.


TOPICS COVERED
Part I: Introduction
January 24 Introduction to Seminar, P2P Technologies, and Copyright
January 31 Social Norms of File Sharing
Part II: Copyright Industry Efforts to Regulate Development of Infringement-Enabling Technologies
February 7 The Sony Betamax Case: Setting Liability Rules for Technologies With Substantial Non-infringing Uses
February 14 Copyright Industry Lawsuits Against Napster And Aimster: Sony Revisited
February 28 MGM v. Grokster: The Sony Standard Challenged
March 7 Legislative Proposals to Change Rules for Technology Developer Liability for Copyright Infringements By Users
Part III: Legal Challenges to File Sharing
March 14 Obtaining User Identity Information From Internet Service Providers
March 28 RIAA v. File Sharers
April 4 Other Measures Aimed at Deterring File-sharing of Copyrighted Works
Part IV: Other Considerations and Strategies for Dealing with the P2P Phenomenon
April 11 Assessing the Effects of File-Sharing on Record Sales and of RIAA Lawsuits on Extent of File-Sharing
April 18 Digital Rights Management Technologies As an Option
April 25 Compulsory Licensing As an Option
May 2 New Business Models as an Option
May 9 International Considerations Pertaining to National Efforts to Regulate P2P File-Sharing and File-Sharing Technologies
Additional Resources
Congressional Hearings About Peer to Peer File Sharing
Useful Sites
back to top

Part I: Introduction

January 24 - Introduction to Seminar, P2P Technologies, and Copyright

Guest speaker: Professor John Chuang, SIMS, UC Berkeley

Required Readings:

Recommended:

January 31 - Social Norms of File Sharing

Required Readings:

Recommended:

Part II: Copyright Industry Efforts to Regulate Development of Infringement-Enabling Technologies

February 7 - The Sony Betamax Case: Setting Liability Rules for Technologies With Substantial Non-infringing Uses

Lecture Slides: PPT (76 kB), PDF, 2/page (116 kB), PDF, 6/page (112 kB)

Required Readings:

Recommended:

February 14 - Copyright Industry Lawsuits Against Napster And Aimster: Sony Revisited

Lecture Slides: PPT (129 kB), PDF, 2/page (127 kB), PDF, 6/page (123 kB)

Required Readings:

Recommended:

February 28 - MGM v. Grokster: The Sony Standard Challenged

MGM v. Grokster Lecture Slides (1 Mar 2005):
PPT (50 kB), PDF, 2/page (106 kB), PDF, 6/page (103 kB)

Prof. Samuelson's Presentation at the Internet Caucus in Washington, D.C. on 9 Feb 2005:
PPT (40 kB), PDF, 2/page (76 kB), PDF, 6/page (76 kB)

Required Readings:

Recommended:

Transcript of MGM v. Grokster Oral Arguments: PDF (145 kB)

MGM v. Grokster Supreme Court Briefs on the Merits


Congressional Hearings About Peer to Peer File Sharing

Useful Sites

This page last updated on: Time-stamp: <2005-04-06 16:06:27>